Premature Scrum Adaptation

What is ScrumBut?

Picture this: You and your team embark on a journey, armed with the promises of agility, collaboration, and efficiency that Scrum, the beloved agile framework, offers.

However, as your journey unfolds, you may realize that you’re not reaping all the expected benefits. This is the realm of ‘Scrumbut.’

Before we dive in What is Scrumbut, I encourage you to watch the podcast episode below to gain a deeper understanding of What is Scrumbut.

Defining Scrumbut – What is Scrumbut?

I’ve heard many people encounter challenges with Scrum implementation. So, let’s delve into the topic of ‘What is Scrumbut?

Scrumbut is like a hidden problem that sneaks into teams trying to use Scrum. It’s the reason why they can’t fully harness Scrum’s power to conquer their challenges and unlock the full potential of their product development endeavors.

To understand What is Scrumbut, let’s dissect it:

At its core, Scrum is a beautifully designed framework with distinct roles, rules, and timeboxes, all meticulously crafted to deliver specific benefits and tackle recurring problems head-on.

Click here for more information on how to fast-track your journey to becoming a Scrum professional.

However, when Scrumbuts comes into play, it’s an admission that Scrum has uncovered an issue—a dysfunction that’s holding the team back.

Now, here’s where the twist comes in: Instead of addressing and resolving this dysfunction, a Scrumbut opts for a different route. It acknowledges the problem but chooses to sidestep it, keeping it out of the spotlight.

In essence, a Scrumbut tweaks Scrum to make the dysfunction less visible, allowing it to persist without the team having to confront it directly.

Imagine it as a magician’s sleight of hand—Scrum exposes the problem, and the Scrumbut magician skillfully distracts your attention, making it appear as though the issue has disappeared, when, in reality, it’s just waiting to resurface.

Origins of the Term “Scrumbut”

The term “Scrumbut” isn’t just a random jumble of letters; it carries with it a history that mirrors the challenges teams face when adopting Scrum.

Its origin can be traced back to the agile community’s collective experience.

It emerged as a way to describe those teams or organizations that professed to practice Scrum but, in reality, were deviating from its fundamental principles and practices.

So, Scrumbut isn’t just an abstract concept; it’s a tangible impediment that, if left unaddressed, can hinder your team’s journey toward agile excellence.

Let’s delve deeper into the signs, symptoms, and strategies to combat the enigma that is Scrumbut, ensuring your Scrum journey is as smooth and effective as possible.

Spotting the Signs of Scrumbut

And now it’s time to explore ‘What is Scrumbut?’ and the signs that can help you identify it within your team or organization.

Think of these signs as red flags that something isn’t quite right with your Scrum practices.

Let’s break it down into two parts: Common Scrumbut Indicators and Recognizing Dysfunctional Practices

Common Scrumbut Indicators

Imagine you’re on a treasure hunt, and these are the clues that lead you to the hidden treasure of Scrumbut:

  1. Incomplete Product Backlog: If your Product Backlog lacks essential details or prioritization, it’s a sign that your team might not be fully committed to Scrum’s principles. For example, if your Product Owner constantly updates the backlog during the sprint, it may indicate a lack of clarity.
  2. Overloaded Sprints: When your team consistently fails to complete all planned work in a sprint, you might be dealing with Scrumbut. For instance, if your team regularly carries over tasks from one sprint to the next without addressing the underlying reasons, it’s a cause for concern.
  3. Lack of Daily Standup Engagement: If team members start skipping or disengaging from the daily standup meetings, it could suggest a disconnect from Scrum’s collaborative spirit. For instance, if team members consistently report their status to the Scrum Master rather than discussing it openly with the team, it’s a potential Scrumbut indicator.
  4. Ignoring Retrospective Feedback: When your team conducts retrospectives but fails to act on the feedback to improve, it’s a sign of Scrumbut. For example, if issues raised in retrospectives remain unresolved sprint after sprint, you may have a Scrumbut problem.
  5. Incomplete Definition of Done: If your team doesn’t have a clear and agreed-upon definition of what “done” means for each user story or task, it can lead to misunderstandings and a lack of transparency. For example, if a user story is considered “done” without proper testing or user acceptance, it’s a Scrumbut indicator.

Recognizing Dysfunctional Practices

Now, let’s shed light on ‘What is Scrumbut?’ and explore some dysfunctional practices that often accompany it:
  1. Hero Culture: If one or a few individuals consistently take on most of the work and heroically step in to save the day, it’s a sign of dysfunctional teamwork. Scrum emphasizes collaboration among team members, and a hero culture goes against this principle.
  2. Micro-Management: When the Scrum Master or Product Owner becomes overly prescriptive or micromanages the team’s work, it can stifle self-organization. For example, if the Product Owner dictates how every user story should be implemented, it’s a dysfunctional practice.
  3. Scope Creep: If new work is constantly added to the sprint backlog during the sprint without proper evaluation and prioritization, it can lead to scope creep. This can hinder the team’s ability to deliver a potentially shippable product increment at the end of the sprint.
  4. Blurred Roles: When Scrum roles and responsibilities become blurred, it can create confusion. For instance, if team members start taking on the responsibilities of the Product Owner or Scrum Master without clear authority or understanding, it’s a dysfunctional practice.
  5. Fear of Open Communication: If team members hesitate to raise issues or express their concerns openly, it can lead to problems going unaddressed. Scrum relies on transparent communication and collaboration, so a culture of fear inhibits its effectiveness.
By keeping an eye out for these common indicators and dysfunctional practices, you’ll be better equipped to identify and address Scrumbut within your team, ensuring a more effective and genuine Scrum implementation.
Image representing the concept of 'Scrumbut' in Agile

Unearthing the Roots of Scrumbut

Now that we’ve learned how to spot the signs of Scrumbut and understand ‘What is Scrumbut,’ it’s time to dig deeper and explore the root causes of this phenomenon.

Scrumbut doesn’t just materialize out of thin air; there are underlying reasons that contribute to its existence. Let’s delve into these root causes:

Organizational Resistance

Imagine your organization as a ship sailing on the vast sea of change. Organizational resistance is like an anchor dragging behind, slowing down the ship’s progress. In the context of Scrumbut, this resistance often arises from:

  1. Legacy Hierarchies: Traditional top-down hierarchies can clash with Scrum’s self-organizing teams. When leadership doesn’t embrace Scrum’s principles and tries to maintain strict control, it can lead to Scrumbut.
  2. Cultural Inertia: Organizations with a long history of command-and-control management may resist the shift to agile and Scrum practices. This resistance can manifest as a reluctance to relinquish control or a fear of losing established power structures.

Lack of Understanding

Imagine you’re trying to solve a complex puzzle without understanding its pieces. A lack of understanding of Scrum and Agile principles can be a major roadblock. Common issues include:

  1. Superficial Training: Teams may undergo Scrum training but lack deep comprehension. This results in a surface-level understanding of Scrum, making it difficult to implement effectively.
  2. Incomplete Education: Stakeholders, including leadership, might not fully grasp the principles behind Scrum. Incomplete education can lead to unrealistic expectations and misalignment with Scrum values.

Fear of Change

Change can be as intimidating as a dark, uncharted forest. Fear often holds teams and organizations back from fully embracing Scrum:

  1. Comfort Zones: People tend to stick with what’s familiar. The prospect of changing established processes and practices can be daunting, especially if those processes have been in place for a long time.
  2. Uncertainty: Change brings uncertainty, and uncertainty can breed fear. Team members may fear the unknown and resist Scrum out of concern for how it might affect their roles or job security.

Misinterpretation of Scrum

Imagine reading a map with the wrong symbols—misinterpretation of Scrum can lead teams down the wrong path:

  1. Cherry-Picking Practices: Teams might cherry-pick certain Scrum practices while ignoring others, leading to an incomplete and ineffective Scrum implementation.
  2. Misaligned Goals: If the team’s goals and Scrum’s goals aren’t aligned, it can result in a misinterpretation of Scrum’s purpose. For instance, focusing solely on delivering more features without considering customer value can lead to a skewed Scrum implementation.

These root causes can intermingle and compound, creating an environment ripe for Scrumbut to thrive.

Grasping the Impact of Scrumbut

Now it’s time to explore the far-reaching consequences of Scrumbut, which can affect not only your teams but also your product development efforts and overall customer satisfaction and business value.

Consequences for Teams

Scrumbut doesn’t just play hide and seek within your Scrum process; it can have profound effects on your team dynamics and morale.

Here are some of the key consequences for teams:

  1. Frustration and Disillusionment: When teams repeatedly encounter the same problems without seeing improvements, frustration sets in. Team members may become disillusioned, leading to decreased motivation and engagement.
  2. Lack of Accountability: Scrumbut practices can blur the lines between responsibility and accountability. Team members may start pointing fingers when things go wrong, eroding trust and collaboration.
  3. Burnout: Constantly carrying over unfinished work from one sprint to the next can lead to burnout. Team members may find themselves working overtime to meet unrealistic expectations, which is unsustainable in the long run.
  4. Stagnation: Scrumbut can lead to a stagnant team that doesn’t evolve or learn from its mistakes. Without the continuous improvement aspect of Scrum, teams miss out on opportunities for growth and innovation.

Implications for Product Development

Scrumbut doesn’t just impact teams—it also has ripple effects on your product development efforts:

  1. Delayed Delivery: The inability to complete planned work within sprints can result in delayed product releases. This can put your product at a competitive disadvantage in the market.
  2. Reduced Product Quality: Rushed development to meet unrealistic expectations can lead to lower product quality. This can result in more defects, increased technical debt, and decreased customer satisfaction.
  3. Inefficient Resource Allocation: Constantly changing priorities and scope can lead to inefficient resource allocation. Valuable time and effort may be wasted on tasks that don’t contribute to the overall product vision.

Customer Satisfaction and Business Value

Ultimately, Scrumbut can impact your customers and the value your business delivers:

  1. Diminished Customer Satisfaction: Customers may experience delays, lower-quality products, and unmet expectations. This can lead to dissatisfaction and potentially drive them to seek alternatives.
  2. Reduced Business Value: Scrumbut practices can hinder your ability to deliver features and enhancements that truly matter to customers. This can limit your business’s ability to remain competitive and innovative.
  3. Risk of Losing Market Share: If your competitors are more agile and can deliver higher-quality products faster, your business may lose market share over time.

Understanding the impact of Scrumbut is essential for recognizing why it’s crucial to address and rectify this issue.

Confronting Scrumbut Head-On

Let’s explore strategies and actions you can take to address Scrumbut within your team or organization. Let’s dive into the three key aspects of addressing Scrumbut:

Steps to Recognize Scrumbut

Before you can combat Scrumbut effectively, you must first recognize its presence. Here are steps to help you spot and acknowledge Scrumbut within your Scrum practices:

  1. Educate Your Team: Ensure that your team understands Scrum’s core principles, values, and practices. This knowledge will help team members identify when Scrumbut practices are creeping in. For the best team learning experience, check out this program.
  2. Regularly Inspect and Adapt: Implement regular retrospectives to reflect on your team’s Scrum implementation. Encourage open and honest discussions about what’s working and what’s not, and be vigilant for signs of Scrumbut.
  3. Seek External Perspective: Sometimes, it takes an external observer, such as an experienced Scrum Master or agile coach, to spot Scrumbut practices that your team might be too close to see.

Strategies for Overcoming Resistance

Overcoming resistance is often the most challenging aspect of addressing Scrumbut. Here are strategies to help you navigate this obstacle:

  1. Education and Training: Provide continuous education and training to both your team and key stakeholders. Help them understand the benefits of Scrum and why certain changes are necessary.
  2. Foster Collaboration: Encourage collaboration and open communication within the team and with stakeholders. Emphasize that Scrum is a team effort and that everyone’s input is valuable.
  3. Lead by Example: As a Scrum Master or team member, lead by example. Demonstrate the benefits of Scrum through your actions and behaviors.
  4. Influence Organizational Change: Advocate for changes at the organizational level if necessary. Engage with leadership to align the organization’s culture and practices with Scrum values.

Creating a Culture of Continuous Improvement

To prevent Scrumbut from resurfacing, it’s essential to instill a culture of continuous improvement:

  1. Retrospectives: Continue conducting regular retrospectives to identify areas for improvement. Ensure that the team acts on the feedback and implements changes in subsequent sprints.
  2. Experimentation and Adaptation: Encourage the team to experiment with new practices and techniques. Be open to adapting your Scrum implementation as you learn and grow.
  3. Empower Teams: Empower your team members to take ownership of their work and make decisions. Encourage self-organization and trust in their ability to make the right choices.
  4. Celebrate Successes: Celebrate both small and large successes. Recognize and reward the team’s achievements and their commitment to Scrum principles.

By following these steps and strategies, you can address Scrumbut and gradually transform your team and organization into a thriving, agile, and Scrum-driven entity.

The Scrum Master’s Crucial Role in Battling Scrumbut

I’m sure you’re curious about the Scrum Master’s role in combating Scrumbut.

The Scrum Master serves as a guide, coach, and catalyst for change. Let’s break down the Scrum Master’s role into three key areas:

Coaching and Education

One of the Scrum Master’s primary responsibilities is to coach and educate the team and stakeholders about Scrum principles and practices.

The Scrum Master can excel in this aspect:

  1. Scrum Workshops: Conduct workshops and training sessions to ensure that everyone understands the fundamentals of Scrum. This includes not just the team but also Product Owners, stakeholders, and leadership.
  2. Continuous Learning: Encourage a culture of continuous learning within the team. Share courses, articles, and books about Scrum and agile practices to help team members deepen their knowledge.
  3. Individual Coaching: Provide one-on-one coaching to team members and stakeholders who may need extra guidance in adopting Scrum practices. Tailor your coaching approach to each individual’s needs.

Facilitating Change

The Scrum Master is also a change agent, responsible for helping the team and organization adapt to Scrum.

Here are strategies to facilitate change effectively:

  1. Identify Roadblocks: Identify and understand the specific challenges and roadblocks that are contributing to Scrumbut. Work with the team to prioritize these issues.
  2. Remove Obstacles: Actively work to remove obstacles that hinder the team’s ability to practice Scrum effectively. This may involve collaborating with leadership to address organizational impediments.
  3. Change Advocacy: Champion the benefits of Scrum and advocate for change within the organization. Be a persuasive advocate for Scrum principles and practices, highlighting the positive impact they can have.

Advocating for Scrum Principles

The Scrum Master plays a crucial role in upholding and advocating for Scrum principles.

Here’s how to do this within your organization:

  1. Lead by Example: Model Scrum values and principles in your own actions and behaviors. Show how Scrum can lead to better outcomes, both for the team and the organization.
  2. Hold to Scrum Principles: Be unwavering in your commitment to Scrum’s core principles. When faced with pressure to compromise on Scrum practices, diplomatically but firmly advocate for adherence.
  3. Educate Stakeholders: Educate stakeholders, including leadership, about the benefits of Scrum. Provide evidence and case studies that demonstrate how Scrum can improve product development.

As a Scrum Master, your role is pivotal in guiding your team through the challenges of Scrumbut and towards a more authentic and successful Scrum implementation.

By providing coaching, facilitating change, and advocating for Scrum principles, you can help your team and organization fully realize the benefits of Scrum and overcome the obstacles of Scrumbut.

Preventing Scrumbut in New Scrum Implementations

When embarking on a new Scrum implementation, it’s essential to start on the right foot to avoid the pitfalls of Scrumbut.

Let me share a couple of tips for ensuring a healthy Scrum start and building a strong foundation:

Steps for a Healthy Scrum Start

Creating a solid foundation from the beginning is key to preventing Scrumbut. Here are the steps to follow:

  1. Comprehensive Training: Ensure that all team members, including the Product Owner and Scrum Master, undergo comprehensive Scrum training. This will help establish a common understanding of Scrum’s principles and practices. [e.g. Agile and Scrum for Business]
  2. Empower the Scrum Team: Encourage the Scrum Team to self-organize and take ownership of their work. Clarify roles and responsibilities, and emphasize that the team collectively owns the product’s success.
  3. Set Realistic Expectations: Be transparent about what Scrum can and cannot achieve. Set realistic expectations with stakeholders and leadership to avoid pressure to compromise on Scrum principles.
  4. Strong Product Ownership: Invest in a capable and dedicated Product Owner who understands the product’s vision, prioritizes effectively, and is available to the team.
  5. Regular Inspection and Adaptation: Establish a cadence of regular ceremonies, including sprint planning, daily standups, and retrospectives, to ensure continuous improvement. Use retrospectives to address issues promptly.

Building a Strong Scrum Foundation

To build a robust Scrum foundation and ward off Scrumbut, consider the following:

  1. Continuous Learning: Encourage a culture of continuous learning and improvement. Encourage team members to stay updated on the latest Agile and Scrum practices.[e.g. follow this Scrum blog]
  2. Embrace Transparency: Foster an environment where transparency is valued. Share sprint goals, progress, and impediments openly with stakeholders to promote trust.
  3. Iterate and Adapt: Scrum is inherently iterative. Emphasize the importance of regularly inspecting and adapting both processes and products to stay aligned with customer needs.
  4. Customer Focus: Keep the customer at the center of your efforts. Regularly solicit feedback and involve customers in the development process to ensure you’re delivering value.
  5. Celebrate Successes: Acknowledge and celebrate team achievements and milestones. Recognize the positive impact that adhering to Scrum principles has on the team’s productivity and product quality.

By following these steps and building a strong foundation, you can significantly reduce the risk of Scrumbut creeping into your Scrum implementation.

NOTE: Scrum is a framework that thrives on a commitment to its principles and continuous improvement. If you decide to stay true to its values, your team and organization will reap the full benefits of agile and Scrum practices.


Recap of Key Takeaways

Throughout this guide, we’ve thoroughly examined ‘What is Scrumbut,’ identified its symptoms, delved into its root causes, and discussed strategies for addressing it.

We’ve seen how Scrumbut can impact teams, product development efforts, and overall customer satisfaction and business value.

Moreover, we’ve uncovered the pivotal role of the Scrum Master in combating Scrumbut and fostering an authentic Scrum environment.

Finally, we’ve discussed the steps for preventing Scrumbut in new Scrum implementations and building a strong Scrum foundation.

In summary, the key takeaways are:

Scrumbut is a deviation from Scrum’s core principles and practices that hinder teams from reaping the full benefits of agile product development.

Scrumbut can be identified through common indicators and dysfunctional practices within teams.

Root causes of Scrumbut include organizational resistance, lack of understanding, fear of change, and misinterpretation of Scrum.

Addressing Scrumbut requires coaching, facilitating change, and advocating for Scrum principles, with the Scrum Master playing a central role.

Preventing Scrumbut in new Scrum implementations involves setting a healthy Scrum start and building a strong Scrum foundation.

The Importance of Staying True to Scrum Principles

To thrive in an ever-evolving business landscape, organizations need the agility and adaptability that Scrum provides.

By staying true to Scrum principles and practices, you unlock the potential for continuous improvement, increased productivity, and the delivery of high-value products to your customers.

However, Scrumbut can be a subtle and persistent adversary. It can derail your Scrum journey, causing frustration, delays, and reduced customer satisfaction.

This guide has provided you with the knowledge and strategies to identify, address, and prevent Scrumbut, all while understanding ‘What is Scrumbut.’ This ensures a more genuine and effective Scrum implementation.

Now, it’s time to put this knowledge into action.

Embrace the values of Scrum—transparency, inspection, adaptation, and commitment—to foster a culture of agility and innovation within your organization.

Check out our Agile Project Management Learning Programs at to dive deeper into the world of Scrum and agile practices.

Thank you for joining us on this journey to understand, combat, and prevent Scrumbut.

May your Scrum implementation be authentic, successful, and truly transformative.

Get new posts by email: